-REQUIRETLS support
-------------------
-Ref: https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-uta-smtp-require-tls-03
-
-If compiled with EXPERIMENTAL_REQUIRETLS support is included for this
-feature, where a REQUIRETLS option is added to the MAIL command.
-The client may not retry in clear if the MAIL+REQUIRETLS fails (or was never
-offered), and the server accepts an obligation that any onward transmission
-by SMTP of the messages accepted will also use REQUIRETLS - or generate a
-fail DSN.
-
-The Exim implementation includes
-- a main-part option tls_advertise_requiretls; host list, default "*"
-- an observability variable $requiretls returning yes/no
-- an ACL "control = requiretls" modifier for setting the requirement
-- Log lines and Received: headers capitalise the S in the protocol
- element: "P=esmtpS"
-
-Differences from spec:
-- we support upgrading the requirement for REQUIRETLS, including adding
- it from cold, withing an MTA. The spec only define the sourcing MUA
- as being able to source the requirement, and makes no mention of upgrade.
-- No support is coded for the RequireTLS header (which can be used
- to annul DANE and/or STS policiy). [can this be done in ACL?]
-
-Note that REQUIRETLS is only advertised once a TLS connection is acheived
-(in contrast to STARTTLS). If you want to check the advertising, do something
-like "swaks -s 127.0.0.1 -tls -q HELO".
+TLS Session Resumption
+----------------------
+TLS Session Resumption for TLS 1.2 and TLS 1.3 connections can be used (defined
+in RFC 5077 for 1.2). The support for this can be included by building with
+EXPERIMENTAL_TLS_RESUME defined. This requires GnuTLS 3.6.3 or OpenSSL 1.1.1
+(or later).
+
+Session resumption (this is the "stateless" variant) involves the server sending
+a "session ticket" to the client on one connection, which can be stored by the
+client and used for a later session. The ticket contains sufficient state for
+the server to reconstruct the TLS session, avoiding some expensive crypto
+calculation and one full packet roundtrip time.
+
+Operational cost/benefit:
+ The extra data being transmitted costs a minor amount, and the client has
+ extra costs in storing and retrieving the data.
+
+ In the Exim/Gnutls implementation the extra cost on an initial connection
+ which is TLS1.2 over a loopback path is about 6ms on 2017-laptop class hardware.
+ The saved cost on a subsequent connection is about 4ms; three or more
+ connections become a net win. On longer network paths, two or more
+ connections will have an average lower startup time thanks to the one
+ saved packet roundtrip. TLS1.3 will save the crypto cpu costs but not any
+ packet roundtrips.
+
+ Since a new hints DB is used, the hints DB maintenance should be updated
+ to additionally handle "tls".
+
+Security aspects:
+ The session ticket is encrypted, but is obviously an additional security
+ vulnarability surface. An attacker able to decrypt it would have access
+ all connections using the resumed session.
+ The session ticket encryption key is not committed to storage by the server
+ and is rotated regularly (OpenSSL: 1hr, and one previous key is used for
+ overlap; GnuTLS 6hr but does not specify any overlap).
+ Tickets have limited lifetime (2hr, and new ones issued after 1hr under
+ OpenSSL. GnuTLS 2hr, appears to not do overlap).
+
+ There is a question-mark over the security of the Diffie-Helman parameters
+ used for session negotiation. TBD. q-value; cf bug 1895
+
+Observability:
+ New log_selector "tls_resumption", appends an asterisk to the tls_cipher "X="
+ element.
+
+ Variables $tls_{in,out}_resumption have bits 0-4 indicating respectively
+ support built, client requested ticket, client offered session,
+ server issued ticket, resume used. A suitable decode list is provided
+ in the builtin macro _RESUME_DECODE for ${listextract {}{}}.
+
+Issues:
+ In a resumed session:
+ $tls_{in,out}_cipher will have values different to the original (under GnuTLS)
+ $tls_{in,out}_ocsp will be "not requested" or "no response", and
+ hosts_require_ocsp will fail
projects / exim.git / blobdiff